top of page

Escalating Costs: The Reality of Over-Specifying Electrical Switchboards

Electrical switchboards serve as the backbone of power distribution systems, ensuring the safe and efficient delivery of electricity within buildings and facilities. However, over-specifying switchboards can lead to unnecessary costs.

  1. IP Rating: The IP (Ingress Protection) rating determines the level of protection against solid particles and liquids that the switchboard enclosure offers. Over-specifying the IP rating by selecting a higher level of protection than necessary can inflate costs. Assessing the specific environmental conditions where the switchboard will be installed is crucial to determine the appropriate IP rating. For example, a switchboard placed indoors in a controlled environment may not require a high IP rating, whereas outdoor or harsh environments necessitate greater protection.

  2. Form Rating: Form rating pertains to the protection against access to hazardous parts within the switchboard and the ingress of solid objects. Over-specifying the form rating can lead to unnecessary expenses. Evaluating the level of physical access required and the potential risks associated with the installation environment is essential. Selecting a higher form rating than needed may result in higher fabrication costs for the switchboard enclosure without providing tangible benefits.

  3. Prospective Fault Current: Accurate determination of the prospective fault current is crucial for selecting appropriate protective devices and designing the switchboard. Over-specifying the prospective fault current can increase costs needlessly. Selecting components with higher ratings, such as circuit breakers and busbars, than required can escalate expenses. Conducting comprehensive fault current calculations and coordination studies is necessary to identify the actual fault current levels and ensure the switchboard is adequately sized.

  4. Load Capacity and Demand: Over-specifying the load capacity of the switchboard by accommodating excessive electrical demand can significantly impact costs. Careful assessment of the anticipated electrical demand, considering current and future requirements, is vital to avoid unnecessary expenses. Specifying a switchboard with a larger load capacity than necessary results in higher upfront costs and ongoing maintenance expenses.

  5. Circuit Protection and Component Sizing: Over-specification can occur in terms of circuit protection by selecting higher-rated protective devices than required. This includes circuit breakers, fuses, and other protective components. Additionally, specifying larger-sized components, such as busbars and cables, beyond what is necessary, can escalate costs. A detailed analysis of the electrical system's characteristics and fault calculations enables the appropriate selection of protection devices and component sizing.

  6. Redundancy and Customization: Integrating redundant features or demanding excessive customization can substantially increase switchboard costs. While redundancy may be crucial in critical applications, unnecessary duplication of components, such as redundant power supplies or duplicate monitoring systems, incurs additional expenses. Similarly, customizing switchboards with non-standard dimensions or unique configurations leads to higher manufacturing complexities, extended lead times, and increased costs for specialized components.

  7. Compliance with Standards: While adherence to safety codes and regulations is essential, over-specifying by insisting on compliance with unnecessary standards can escalate expenses. Thorough evaluation of the applicable standards helps identify the essential requirements, preventing unnecessary expenditures on non-mandatory features or certifications.

  8. Maintenance, Training, and Service Costs: Over-specifying switchboards can also impact long-term expenses. Complex switchboards with excessive features and components require specialized training for personnel and entail higher maintenance costs. Troubleshooting and servicing such systems become more challenging, resulting in increased service expenses and prolonged downtime.

Over-specifying electrical switchboards, including factors such as IP rating, form rating, prospective fault current, and other considerations, can lead to significant cost escalation in electrical installations. Careful evaluation of the actual requirements, considering environmental conditions, load capacity, circuit protection, and customization needs, is essential. Collaboration with experienced professionals and conducting thorough assessments ensures that switchboards are specified accurately, balancing functionality, safety, and costs to optimize the overall electrical system.

112 views0 comments
bottom of page